Supplements and Good Ideas: Do You Really Need All of Them?

Dr. Douglas Christianson • September 11, 2026

Share this article

Supplements and Good Ideas: Do You Really Need All of Them?

Walk into any supplement store or spend ten minutes on social media and you'll probably discover something new that you apparently need.


One person says you need magnesium. Another says creatine. Then it's CoQ10, vitamin D, methylated B vitamins, probiotics, adaptogens, greens powder, mushroom extracts, and the newest supplement that is going to change everything.


Before you know it, you're taking 15 or 20 supplements every morning and you're not entirely sure why you're taking half of them.


I see this all the time.


The problem isn't necessarily that these supplements are bad.


Many of them are good ideas.


But a good idea isn't automatically a good idea for you.


When I see a patient taking a long list of supplements, one of the first things I want to understand is why each one is there.


What are we trying to accomplish?


Was it recommended based on a deficiency? A symptom? A health condition? Lab work? A specific goal?

Or did someone on the internet say everyone should take it?


Supplements should have a purpose.


If we're adding product after product without knowing what we're trying to change, eventually we create so much noise that it's difficult to know what's actually helping.


You feel better. Why?


You feel worse. Which supplement caused it?


Your labs change. What made the difference?


When you're taking 20 different things, those questions become surprisingly difficult to answer.


I Don't Have a “Perfect Stack”


Patients sometimes ask me:

“What supplements should every man take?”

Or, “What's your longevity stack?”


I don't really have one.


That's because the supplements I recommend depend on the person sitting in front of me.


Your diet, medications, laboratory results, medical history, sleep, exercise, symptoms, age, goals, and existing supplements all influence what may or may not make sense.


Someone working on cardiovascular health may need a very different approach than someone focused on digestive health, athletic recovery, metabolic health, or correcting a nutritional deficiency.


That's individualized medicine.


I like supplements. I use them in my practice.


But I think of them as tools, not collectibles.


Sometimes the right tool is a supplement. Sometimes it's nutrition. Sometimes it's exercise, better sleep, a medication, or simply removing something that isn't helping.


And sometimes the best thing I can do is tell a patient:

“You don't need that.” (Which sometimes makes them want it more lol)


My goal isn't to see how many products I can add to your plan. It's to figure out which interventions actually fit your clinical picture.


I would rather have you taking a few things with a clear purpose than swallowing 20 capsules because 20 different people had 20 different good ideas.


Because when it comes to supplements, more isn't necessarily better. Better decisions are better.


- Dr. C



Recent Posts

By Dr. Douglas Christianson September 11, 2026
Tadalafil: More Than an ED Medication? 
By Dr. Douglas Christianson September 11, 2026
Marijuana for Sleep: Is It Actually Helping? 
By Dr. Douglas Christianson September 11, 2026
Sleep: The One Thing That Can Throw Everything Off 
By Dr. Douglas Christianson September 11, 2026
Why Testosterone Therapy Is a Lifestyle, Not Just a Prescription
By Dr. Douglas Christainson September 11, 2026
NAD+: What Is It and Why Is Everyone Talking About It?
By Dr. Douglas Christianson September 11, 2026
When I tell someone we are a Naturopathic Doctor, one of the first questions we get is: “So…what exactly does that mean?” It's a fair question. Some people assume naturopathic medicine means we only use herbs and supplements. Others think it means we are against medications or conventional medicine. Neither is how we practice. So, What Is a Naturopathic Doctor? A licensed Naturopathic Doctor, or NMD/ND, attends an accredited four-year naturopathic medical school and is trained in medical sciences, physical examination, laboratory testing, diagnosis, pharmacology, nutrition, botanical medicine, and other therapeutic approaches. What makes naturopathic medicine different is often how we approach the patient. When someone comes into our office with fatigue, weight gain, low testosterone, high blood pressure, digestive problems, or another concern, We don't want to only ask: “What can we give you for this symptom?” We also want to ask: “Why might this be happening?” We Use Natural and Conventional Medicine We don't believe healthcare has to be divided into two teams. Sometimes nutrition and lifestyle changes are appropriate. Sometimes we may use nutritional supplements, botanical medicine, or other natural therapies. And sometimes medication is absolutely appropriate. Our job isn't to choose a treatment because it is “natural” or “conventional.” Our job is to determine what makes sense for the individual sitting in front of me. For example, if someone has high blood pressure, we may talk about sleep, exercise, nutrition, stress, body composition, and metabolic health. But if that blood pressure requires medication, we are not going to ignore it simply because medication isn't “natural.” There is a time and place for both. Why Our Appointments May Feel Different One of the biggest differences patients notice is how much we talk. We want to understand your health history, symptoms, medications, supplements, diet, exercise, sleep, stress, goals, and laboratory findings. Those details help me connect the dots. If you're exhausted every afternoon, for example, we don't automatically assume you need testosterone, a vitamin, or another supplement. We want to understand your sleep, hormones, thyroid, blood sugar regulation, nutrition, medications, stress, and overall health before deciding what makes sense. Our Goal Is to Help You Understand Your Health We believe patients should understand why we're doing something. If we recommend a treatment, laboratory test, medication, supplement, or lifestyle change, we want you to understand the reasoning behind it. That's what naturopathic medicine means to us. It's not about choosing natural medicine over conventional medicine. It's about looking at the whole person, asking better questions, and using the tools available to help you become healthier. That's the kind of medicine we practice. -Dr. C and Dr. B
By Dr. Douglas Christianson September 11, 2026
You’re tired. Your motivation isn’t what it used to be. Your workouts feel harder to recover from. Maybe your sex drive has dropped, you’re gaining weight more easily, or you simply don’t feel like yourself. So, you get your testosterone checked. The result comes back “normal.” But you still don’t feel good. So, what’s going on? This is something I see frequently in men who come to see me. They have symptoms that sound like low testosterone, but they’ve been told their testosterone is normal and that everything looks fine. The problem is that testosterone is only one piece of the puzzle. When I evaluate a man’s hormones, I don't only want to know his total testosterone. I want to understand the bigger hormonal picture. Total testosterone tells us how much testosterone is circulating in the blood, but I may also look at free testosterone, SHBG, estradiol, ultra sensitive estradiol and the hormones responsible for signaling testosterone production. More importantly, I want to know why you're having symptoms in the first place. What If It Isn't Your Testosterone? Fatigue, low libido, brain fog, decreased motivation, weight gain, and poor exercise recovery can happen with low testosterone, but testosterone isn't the only thing that can cause them. I also think about sleep quality and sleep apnea, thyroid function, blood sugar regulation, metabolic health, nutrition, medications, stress, exercise, and recovery. Sometimes testosterone is part of the problem. Sometimes it isn't. And sometimes several things are happening at the same time. That's why I don't believe in treating a testosterone number without understanding the man attached to it. “Normal” Doesn't Mean I Stop Looking Reference ranges are useful, but they're not the end of the conversation. If your testosterone is within the laboratory range but you still don't feel like yourself, my next question isn't automatically: “How can we raise your testosterone?” My question is: “Why do you feel this way?” That's where the real investigation begins. I may need to look deeper into your hormones, sleep, metabolic health, cardiovascular health, thyroid function, nutrition, exercise, medications, stress, or other areas based on your history and symptoms. The goal isn't to chase a testosterone number. The goal is to understand what your body is telling us. Looking at the Whole Picture Men's health is rarely about one hormone. Energy, libido, body composition, cardiovascular health, sleep, metabolism, mood, and performance are all connected. When something starts to change, I want to understand why before deciding what we should do about it. If you've been told your testosterone is “normal” but you still don't feel like yourself, there may be more to the story. that's exactly what I want to help you figure out. Your testosterone level is one piece of the puzzle. Let's look at the whole picture. -Dr. C